While it’s generally accepted that sludge metal took root in in the working-class neighborhoods of 1980s New Orleans (following the Melvins’ famous tour) and, more broadly, in the swampy backwaters of the deep South, it has since spread like a nasty fever and taken on many forms. Chat Pile are the noisy offspring, as their sound is rustier than murky, taking its essence from the stronghold in Oklahoma City. Never too high on the go-to places in the U.S., this city shattered by unemployment and poverty, with a past rooted in oil and mining, is the capital of a state shaped like an old meat grinder…
Following their strong debut albums God’s Country (2022) and Cool World (2024), and the excellent In the Earth Again — a collaborative record with guitarist Hayden Pedigo (2025) — this third studio album stays true to their roots: raw, heavy music that tears through a tattered American Dream, lyrics that evoke with disgust a violent and toxic present, screamed and chanted vocals that sound like the echo of a waking nightmare. Listening to Chat Pile is like experiencing the cold, mundane feeling you get when standing in front of an ATM that’s just swallowed your credit card, while you stand there sweating, clutching another bill reminder, fully aware that AI will soon take over your already precarious job.
Who Loves the Sun drops no question mark, though: the foursome seems to assert that no one walking under the sun today finds any joy in it, and that everything is destined to vanish under the scorching sun that destroys our world and every last shred of hope. The album cover itself clearly depicts this vision of a dehumanized world slowly baking in the heat, where the shade is nothing but a refuge of misery and loneliness. The sweltering summer we’ve just endured only confirms their message…
The in-your-face energy that radiates from the first notes feels as if we’ve been teleported to the dusty streets of a large, life-devoid city, at the foot of a skyline bathed in blazing sunlight. From the album opener “Creature”, Raygun Busch alternates between clear, calm vocals and frenzied screams to warn us that civilization has vanished beneath the ashes, and that no one has escaped. Not even the powerful. Chat Pile creates an atmosphere that shifts between heat and cold, calm and storm — like a madman caught between two bouts of insanity — by alternating edgy tracks and more subdued ones, none of them feeling like a filler.
You’re swept away by the heavy, grinding, near-nu-metal bass, Raygun Busch’s intense, angry vocals, while the guitar gives the melodies center stage and adds Chat Pile’s signature dissonance. The tracks flow seamlessly: touches of new wave on “Same Rules” and hardcore on the anthemic “Intruder”, some Neurosian bits on the excellent “Shrine”. And we’re left wanting more, as with the incredibly raw “PEN I S MALL”. The closing track “October All The Time” — which stands almost as a departure from the rest — concludes this intense album with a more folk-inspired feel. This leaves the album’s central question hanging: does it really matter if everything we know disappears?
With an already compelling discography, Chat Pile really drives the rusty nail home with this album — one that any depressed, Prozac-deprived, eco-anxious person definitely should not spin. A highly successful record, imbued with uncompromising depictions of a world in ruins… Let’s rejoice, my brothers: it’s all over!
Last modified: 28 septembre 2026

