There are bands whose every album we await with that somewhat irrational dual sense of anticipation: the hope that it will be even better, and the fear that it won’t be the same anymore. All Them Witches is one of those bands. The blues, the psychedelia and long hypnotic build-ups, Charles Michael Parks Jr.’s soulful vocals… Their masterful Hellfest 2024 performance is still stuck in our heads. The bar was set high. Very high.
House of Mirrors arrives under unusual circumstances: the departure of founding drummer Robby Staebler, who laid the rhythmic foundation of the entire All Them Witches sound. One might have wondered if his (now former) bandmates would try to compensate, overplay, or beef up the sound to fill the void. They did none of that. What they did was focus on crafting SONGS. And that is both their best decision and the source of real frustration.
It has to be said that the first few listens can leave a mixed impression, especially since the album’s doom-laden opening track and single “Red Rocking Chair” is enough to throw you off, as it doesn’t match what we subconsciously expect from the band. When we think of All Them Witches, we often think of those long, drawn-out compositions. We think of the atmospheres of “Dying Surfer Meets His Maker”, the soaring passages of “Lightning at the Door” or the impressive mastery of “Nothing As The Ideal”. All this feels less present on this album: the tracks are shorter, more direct, and often more structured.
We’re looking for those long psychedelic builds, the instrumental detours, and those suspended moments that the band is so good at crafting. But House of Mirrors doesn’t really play that card. It prefers to focus on the essentials: the songs. And that’s precisely where the album starts to really take off. You start to remember the tracks. To pick out your favorites. To revisit certain vocal passages. To hum certain melodies hours after the album ends. In short, you start listening to songs rather than a whole.
All Them Witches has rarely released an album so focused on songwriting. Each track seems designed to stand on its own. The lush arrangements serve the song rather than merely creating an atmospheric display. Parks Jr.’s voice, more front and center than ever, is carried by more accessible melodies and ends up resonating differently — certain choruses stick with you long after just a few listens.
Musically, the band has lost none of its identity. The blues and psychedelia are there, and their instantly recognizable atmospheres remain intact. But All Them Witches now seems more interested in refining its sound than in expanding it. This choice may divide opinion. Fans of long instrumental explorations may find the whole thing a bit tame. Conversely, those who appreciate albums that reveal themselves gradually might well see this as one of their most accomplished records in terms of songwriting. The context of their drummer’s departure also makes this album interesting: the response from the other members is ultimately quite elegant and much more subtle.
Ultimately, House of Mirrors is probably not All Them Witches’ most spectacular album. It doesn’t necessarily reach the emotional heights of Nothing As The Ideal or offer the same sense of escape as some of its predecessors. On the other hand, it might well be one of their most cohesive and enduring albums. It’s a record that doesn’t reveal itself right away. Once the songs finally take root, the mirror promised by its title delivers on its promise: what it reveals depends on the patience you give it and reflects only what you’re willing to look for there.

ARTIST: All Them Witches
ALBUM: House of Mirrors
RELEASED: 29th May 2026
LABEL: BMG Records
GENRE: Heavy blues rock
Last modified: 8 juin 2026

